The first three cases follow a 350-person software company from its first medical quote to its first July paycheck. Three more show how HR and Finance would handle the cost of family coverage, a change in prescription coverage and an acquisition just before renewal.
Illustrative case study
Would we switch networks for $66,000 if it meant losing a hospital?
It’s April. A 350-person software company is comparing two July medical renewals for its teams in California, Texas, New York and Massachusetts. The lower quote looks attractive. HR spots a Boston-area hospital in the current directory and can’t find its campus in the proposed network.
Employee-only coverage at assumed rates
Contribution
Keep network
Switch network
Employer per month, per enrollee
$620
$595
Employee per month, per enrollee
$165
$160
Employer total for 12 months
$1,636,800
$1,570,800
Assumes 220 people enrolled in employee-only coverage for 12 months under either option. Other tiers, fees and employee out-of-pocket costs are outside this calculation.
What we would do
HR
Give Laura the hospital campus and the locations the team needs checked. Use aggregate headcounts for the first discussion.
Laura’s team
Match each quote to its exact network, request written confirmation for that campus and check an alternative facility with HR. Flag unresolved access alongside the price.
Carrier and Finance
The carrier confirms participation for July 1. Finance records whether the contribution difference justifies any disruption before HR announces a plan.
What if a lower expected cost puts us over budget in a bad year?
It’s May. The same four-state software company has set a $2.70 million employer medical budget for July through June. Its CFO is comparing a fully insured renewal with a self-funded proposal. The second option has a lower expected cost, but the employer would take on claims risk.
Illustrative annual employer costs across all coverage tiers
Funding assumption
Annual cost
Against budget
Fully insured renewal
$2.64M
$60k under
Self-funded, expected claims
$2.50M
$200k under
Self-funded, higher claims
$2.78M
$80k over
All three figures assume the same enrollment and employee contributions. The self-funded figures include assumed claims, administration and stop-loss premiums. The higher-claims figure is one modeled year. The contract determines actual exposure.
What we would do
HR and Finance
Provide the current renewal and contribution schedule. Finance sets the annual budget and says how much cash it could release in a high-claims month. Exchange any detailed claims data through the agreed secure process.
Laura’s team
Put the two proposals on the same 12-month basis. Ask the administrator and stop-loss carrier to document fees, exclusions, reimbursement timing and who pays claims that arrive after the plan year.
Finance
Review the monthly cash requirement and the written terms before choosing which risk the business can carry.
Whose job is it when payroll and the carrier disagree?
It’s June. The four-state employer is preparing its first July payroll. Forty employees requested an increase in voluntary life coverage. Payroll has staged deductions for all 40 increases. The carrier has confirmed 36 and is still reviewing four. HR needs an answer before payroll closes.
What the reconciliation sheet would show
Group
What happens next
36 confirmed increases
Match the approved amounts and effective dates to payroll before releasing the deductions.
4 pending increases
Separate the requested increase from existing coverage. Flag the four deductions for review before payroll closes.
What we would do
Laura’s team
Compare HR’s election summary, the carrier’s confirmations and payroll’s staged deductions through the agreed secure process. Give each mismatch an owner and a due date tied to payroll cutoff.
Carrier
Confirm the amount already in force, any evidence of insurability still needed and the effective date of an approved increase. The employee sends requested health information directly through the carrier’s designated channel.
HR and payroll
HR explains the next step privately to each affected employee. Payroll applies the carrier-confirmed dates and amounts under the employer’s instructions. SSGI would help HR check the first invoice and follow up on open items.
A 350-person software company has 180 employee-only enrollments and 70 family enrollments. At July renewal, employee-only premiums would rise $35 a month and family premiums $140. The CFO can add $75,000 a year toward these two tiers. HR wants to know which employees would absorb the increase.
What SSGI would do
Laura’s team would show each tier’s current and proposed payroll cost. Adding $25 a month for each of the 250 enrollments uses the entire budget. Another allocation adds $15 per employee-only enrollment and $50 per family enrollment, using $74,400. HR would check actual tier participation and payroll frequency before communicating either option.
The medical network looks familiar, but the prescription list changes
A 380-person technology company is comparing July medical quotes. The proposed pharmacy benefit moves a maintenance drug to a different tier. Its summary is silent on existing authorizations. HR cannot tell employees what will happen at their next refill.
What SSGI would do
Use aggregate information to identify the questions, then ask the carrier or pharmacy administrator for the exact formulary, effective date, transition-fill rules and authorization process. HR would prepare a private route for individual questions. The plan administrator would confirm the terms for each applicable plan.
A 320-person software employer plans to acquire a 65-person services business on June 1. Group medical renews July 1. The deal team has assumed both groups can join the buyer’s plan at closing. The carriers have not confirmed that date.
What SSGI would do
HR would map the two employers, eligible groups, current coverage and proposed transition dates. Laura’s team would ask the carriers and administrators for written acceptance, effective dates and enrollment deadlines. The employer’s advisers would address deal-specific obligations. HR would prepare communication for both a June transition and a July transition.