Employer carrier guides · National and multi-state

Aetna vs. Cigna for a multi-state employer

Why would an employer choose Aetna over Cigna, or the other way around? Start with the network and pharmacy terms in each offer. A plan that fits the headquarters can still disrupt care for a remote team.

Illustrative case study

Can a remote hire keep their specialist?

A technology company with 350 people in four states renews in July. The two proposals use similar office-visit copays. HR has confirmed the hospital campus near headquarters but has no written answer about the specialist group serving remote employees.

HR brings
List work locations and priority facilities. Ask the incumbent and challenger for their proposed network names and pharmacy terms.
Laura’s team checks
Compare the named networks at the same addresses, document open items and identify who can confirm each one before enrollment.

What to ask each finalist

Aetna proposal

Ask for the exact network on the quote and look up the specialist by practice address. Confirm the facility and physician group separately. If pharmacy coverage is priced separately, include that cost in the comparison.

Cigna proposal

Request the quoted medical network and prescription drug list. Check the same practice and prescriptions using the same effective date. Record whether referrals, prior authorization or an exception would affect continuity.

Both proposals

Put employer contributions and employee payroll deductions on the same enrollment assumptions. Have each carrier identify who resolves a directory discrepancy before HR communicates a change.

What HR can forward to Finance

The copays look similar. We’ll bring back the annual employer cost, the employee deduction by tier and written confirmation for the remote specialist before recommending a finalist.

Bring the two proposals to Laura’s team

Start with your company size, work locations and renewal month. Laura’s team can arrange a secure way to share census or employee-level details after initial contact.

Ask Laura to compare Aetna and Cigna for our workforce

Carrier sources

Check the proposed product, network and effective date with the carrier for your group.