Carrier guides · Medical · New Jersey

Horizon vs. Aetna for New Jersey employers

Test a routine appointment on both sides of the state line before choosing a medical plan for a New Jersey workforce.

Illustrative employer example

Can a commuter keep a specialist near home?

A Newark technology company has 420 employees. Some work in New Jersey and live in New York or Pennsylvania. A lower payroll deduction looks attractive, but HR still needs to know where employees and dependents can book routine visits.

HR brings
Choose a primary care practice in New Jersey, a specialist in New York and a family practice in Pennsylvania. Use the practice address and the exact plan names.
Get in writing
Ask each carrier to confirm eligibility, scheduled care, network tier, referrals and member cost for the same three visits.

Where the proposals can differ

Horizon BCBSNJ

Horizon lists BlueCard PPO and Horizon HMO among its midsize group offerings. Use the product on the quote to check the commuter’s practice and its cost tier.

Read Horizon BCBSNJ’s employer materials

Aetna

Aetna describes several employer network options. Ask for the directory for the quoted network, then check the same practices for scheduled care and any referral requirement.

Read Aetna’s employer materials

Two checks before you choose

Price the same scheduled visit
Choose the same coverage tier and deductible position. Ask each carrier what the member pays for an office visit and whether a separately billed facility charge applies.
Count who would need another arrangement
Use aggregate enrollment by home state. Record how many covered employees would need a different network option and price that option before presenting the annual difference.
Open the one-page commuter worksheet

What HR can forward to Finance

Illustrative renewal: a $20 lower monthly employer contribution for 300 enrolled employees would reduce annual contributions by $72,000. If 40 of those employees need a different option costing the employer an extra $50 per month, the difference falls to $48,000. Confirm the routine-care checks before using either figure in the budget.

Review these proposals with SSGI Benefits

Start with your company size, work locations and renewal month. SSGI can arrange secure document sharing after the initial conversation.

Ask SSGI to compare Horizon and Aetna