Carrier guides · Medical · California
Kaiser Permanente vs. UnitedHealthcare for Silicon Valley employers
Compare routine care for a San Jose team and its remote employees before Finance signs off on the July renewal.
Illustrative employer example
Could everyone book a routine visit after July 1?
A San Jose tech company has 350 employees in California, Washington, Texas and Colorado. Its VP of People wants to keep a specialist at Stanford in reach. A Texas hire needs a primary care office accepting new patients. Both questions matter to the renewal.
- HR brings
- Bring the exact plan and network on each quote, the specialist’s practice address and the three remote work locations. Use aggregate enrollment by tier to compare costs.
- Get in writing
- Ask each finalist for the routine-care arrangement at each location, any referral required and the effective date of its answer. Leave an unconfirmed practice open on the Finance brief.
Where the proposals can differ
Kaiser Permanente
Kaiser’s large-group guide describes its integrated care model and several plan designs. Ask which option the proposal offers in each state and how a remote employee would schedule an ordinary office visit.
Read Kaiser Permanente’s employer materials (PDF)UnitedHealthcare
UnitedHealthcare describes open-access and primary-care-based plans. Use the network printed on the quote to check the specialist’s practice and the Texas primary care office, including referrals and the employee’s cost.
Read UnitedHealthcare’s employer materialsTwo checks before you choose
- Call the practice an employee would visit
- Check the clinician and location separately from the hospital name. Record the directory result, what the practice confirmed about new patients and what the carrier confirmed about participation on July 1.
- Price the workforce that can use each option
- Use the same enrolled tiers and employer contribution rule for both quotes. If a separate option is needed for one worksite, include its enrollment and price before calculating a company-wide difference.
What HR can forward to Finance
Illustrative July renewal. At the same tier mix, $20 less per month in employer contributions across 250 enrollments would save $60,000 over 12 months. If 50 of those enrollments instead need a remote option costing the employer $35 more than that proposal each month, the annual saving falls to $39,000. Obtain the specialist and remote primary care answers before budgeting the difference.
Review these proposals with SSGI Benefits
Start with your company size, work locations and renewal month. SSGI can arrange secure document sharing after the initial conversation.
Check our four-state network